Mayor on Sandy: 'I'm Not Sticking Up for JCP&L'
James Barberio tempers previous praise of the utility company for helping the Puddingstone area during the storm.
The issue of Jersey Central Power and Light's performance during Superstorm Sandy arose during the Parsippany Township Council's Tuesday night regular meeting at Town Hall. During the public comment portion of the meeting, Mayor James Barberio softened a statement he made last week praising the utility.
At the Nov. 20 council agenda meeting, Barberio finally revealed serious problems—including a close call for the town's sewer plant—faced while dealing with the storm and massive power outages that affected more than half the town.
Among other things, Barberio last week mentioned the plight of residents in Parsippany's Puddingstone neighborhood who ended up trapped in their homes due to downed trees and wires.
"[JCP&L] came to the rescue for Puddingstone," the mayor then asserted. "That was a concerted effort between [the Office of Emergency Management] and the administration to get there immediately, because with no way to get in or out, we had no way to get emergency vehicles in there. That's what we were faced with that night."
However, this week brought the public revelation that residents were trapped in their homes for five days before the utility "came to the rescue."
During the public portion of Tuesday's meeting, there was praise for the police department and its use of the Internet and social media to pass some information to residents during Sandy. There also was criticism of JCP&L's widely perceived lack of communication and prompt action regarding restoring power for many town residents.
"The township and the police department did put out information," Barberio said. "There was a lot of major, major damage done. Not just downed wires, but [damaged] substations."
Regarding JCP&L, the mayor conceded that things were not perfect.
"There was communication, sometimes there was lack of communication," he said. "We're going to look into it."
He added that a group of mayors of Morris County municipalities will meet "soon" to discuss Sandy recovery and the utility's performance.
Councilman Paul Carifi Jr. noted that the Puddingstone situation showed that a better, faster response by JCP&L is needed.
"There's one way in or out [of Puddingstone]," Carifi said. "Five days [of leaving people trapped] is crazy."
"I'm not sticking up for JCP&L," said Mayor Barberio, "but after the fifth day, we called JCP&L and they came within two hours."
"Areas like that—and hospitals—need to be a top priority," said Carifi.
Councilman Michael dePierro suggested that "one key spokesman" from OEM should be designated to stay in contact with a utility pointperson.
Barberio said there was a chosen contact to deal with JCP&L—OEM's second-in-command, Capt. Jeffrey T. Storms.
The mayor said that more of the Sandy story, including the responsiveness of the utility company, will be revealed when Parsippany Police Chief Anthony DeZenzo and Capt. Storms address the Town Council Dec. 11.
"Why did [rescuing Puddingstone] take five days?" asked Council Vice President Vincent Ferrara.
"It was a mess out there," dePierro explained. "They had 4,000 telephone poles down, [and] they ran out of poles. This was a massive thing."
The mayor agreed.
"Eighty-seven percent of Parsippany was out [of power]," he said, adding that the police headquarters, Town Hall and the water department were among those dealing without electricity during the height of the superstorm.
"The priority became sewer and water," said Barberio. "And then we had other issues, health issues. ... Some areas took five days, some took more. It was that massive of a storm."
Councilman dePierro said a deeper look into the utility's performance and the nature of the storm is needed.
"Moving forward, the discussion I would like is [about] the power company," he said. "I know it's expensive, if they look at the total cost ... of putting some lines underground. Not the primary lines or the secondary lines, but the local telephone lines. It's expensive to do this, but maybe they could do an ongoing project over [several] years, so they can't get damaged."
No resolution was reached regarding that point, but the mayor summed up the discussion on an ominous note.
Noting that further talks regarding the utility and storm response are essential, and alluding to his experiences leading the town during last year's Irene and Snowtober and this year's superstorm and nor'easter, Barberio said an eye must be kept on the future.
"We're going to look into it all," the mayor said regarding the need to be ready to deal with disasters. "We're getting megastorms in Parsippany."
Bob Crawford
6:28 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
It's good to see that Mayor Barberio and the Town Council have finally acknowledged the need to begin to plan and prepare for the possibity that more "megastorms" may hit Parsippany. Unlike our elected leaders' past unwillingness and failure to learn from Irene (which they concluded was a once in a hundred year storm requiring them to do nothing ) and unlike the Mayor's declaration that anyone questioning his preparation for and response to Irene was doing so for "political reasons", it sounds as though there has been a change in thinking in Town Hall. That can olny be for the better because the next storm could bring both Sandy's winds and Irene's water. Hopefully at the public meeting on December 11, we will not only hear about the havoc wreaked by Sandy but we will also learn about what the Mayor and Town Council plan to do differently. As the old saying goes three strikes and you are out and given the Administration's storm managment response to date the count is 0 and 2 and the next pitch could come with the next weather pattern. Parsippany can't afford a third strike so it's time for the Mayor and the Town Council to hit one out of the park. Batter up !!
gina s.
6:50 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Bob please stop criticizing everything. During times like this we need to work together and help support each other. Your negativity is just draining. This storm was terrible for all of us who lost power for a week or more, but it's not the mayor, the governor, the president or anyone else's fault. We need to come together and just make sure we are as prepared as we can be for the next one.
Angelina
9:08 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
i agree. He seriously is a miserable person.
dirtpile
6:59 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
I love the way the Mayor and police pat themselves on the back for "all their good work". Five days and two hours, a real record breaker there. The OEM didn't seem so stand out compared to the last years hurricane and for some reason it's all the Mayor talks about. I guess its because of the changes he made and well, someone has has to talk about how great it is. I have not seen much written about all the different volunteers, the hours they gave, unpaid, compared to the ever so great administration and DeZenzo and Storms. I guess volunteer who spend time away from their families, put their lives as risk, put others ahead of themselves really mean nothing to Parsippany. Of course, talking about how great the administration, Chief and Barney Fife are is to deflect the overtime paid from the mind of the tax paying, left to sit five days, two hour Puddingstone resident.
Mike
7:39 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Forget the volunteers that work and donate their time for free. What about some of those officers that got time and a half in overtime pay. I would like to see who got all the hours...50 hours @ time and a half comes to a lot of money for these officers. That's like $100.00 to $130.00 an hour.
Anya Sheiffele
6:59 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
So, the truth over Puddingstone is finally discussed. This one is quite simple - the mayor has put newly minted Capt Jeffrey Storms is the the contact to JCPL and it was his responsibility to communicate issues.....that's a BIG failure in my judgement. Clearly leaving that many people with no way out for 5 days was compromising life & safety of residents that could have had enormous implications. You all got VERY lucky wi this round of poor judgement.....
Jeff
10:28 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Yes - well worth the promotion to further push the already top heavy police department. 5 days is ridiculous - serious changes should be made as this is inexcusable.
Renee
9:07 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
"I'm not sticking up for JCP&L," said Mayor Barberio, "but after the fifth day, we called JCP&L and they came within two hours."
Was this the first time JCP&L was called by the town? On the 5th day? I'm glad they responded in two hours, but it seems like they should have been called MANY times before the 5th day since these residents could not leave their homes. The town should have stepped in right away.
Without knowing anything about that neighborhood, it sounds like there were serious risks that should have been addressed within the first few days. If someone died b/c they couldn't get to the hospital on day 2, 3 or 4, who would be responsible for that?
The town did some great things during this storm. But it sounds like Puddingstone may have been a ball that was dropped by BOTH the town and JCP&L. IF the town had been calling JCP&L repeatedly about this neighborhood, it didn't come through in the article.
Richard Shiple
8:46 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012
"who would be responsible for that?"......It's not enough to look to blame in instances where people actually did get hurt, we now have to assign hypothetical blame in instances where nobody got hurt. This thinking shows exactly what's wrong with this country and what we've become. People are more concerned with looking for somebody to blame than anything else. Instead of looking to blame somebody for something that didn't happen, why not be thankful that it didn't happen in the first place?
Renee
11:06 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Actually, Richard, I'm not looking to blame. I'm looking for prevention and safety. We can't prevent everything in this world. But, I do believe that extra phone calls from town officials could have prevented this dangerous situation of 5 days without people being able to leave their homes. It's unrealistic to think JCP&L could have restored power with so many outages. But clearing paths so people could leave their homes should have been a priority. A priority over power restoration. A 5 day wait doesn't sound like a priority to me. We are lucky, and I am grateful, that nothing happened that would have required a hospital visit, since they wouldn't have been able to get to the hospital.
Angelina
9:09 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
I bet everyone is glad they put Capt. Storms in his new position this year, eh? He can't even do his job properly. 5 days. Shame on him.
Natalie Davis
10:03 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Renee, if the town had been calling JCP&L repeatedly about Puddingstone—and I am not saying it did or didn't call—it didn't come through in what was said during the meeting. As the mayor has not responded to my requests for information, what's said during the meeting is what I'm left with.
Renee
11:11 am on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
I totally understand, Natalie. Just something I noted, not questioning your reporting. I'd venture to bet that if they had been calling repeatedly, they would have said so and probably would have emphasized it.
Bob Crawford
8:40 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Ange
I would have to disagree with your comment above. I don't think Mayor Barberio is a "seriously miserable person" I think he is overwhelmed and is perhaps better suited to be the Mayor of a one stop light town. Parsippany has a great deal of potential but faces a number of complex and serious economic and safety challenges that require a Mayor and a Town Council who welcome and encourage all points of view. The "my way or the highway" philosophy currently being espoused by the Mayor is a leadership path that will lead to nowhere which is a place Parsippany can ill afford to go.
gina s.
6:20 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Bob I'm sorry but the only one that comes across as miserable is you. You never have one positive thing to say....just criticism of everyone and everything. Why not try to bring positivity once and a while?
Robyn M.
12:13 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012
Anyone who doesn't think the Mayor lacks good judgement must lack it themselves, as well. He constantly speaks before he consults with anyone and makes unsophisticated, knee-jerk decisions. This includes the letter supporting the drug addict, the TV infomercial we almost got stuck for, the backdoor Field of Dreams discussions and storm management planning after Irene. I have nothing against him personally, don't know him and have no political aspirations. This is just an opinion based on what I see.
Angelina
4:12 pm on Friday, November 30, 2012
If they dont agree with you, you have nothing good to say about anything or anyone. You are the most negative person on here. I dont know how you never get embarrassed by this stereotype you have placed upon yourself by the things you say every single day on every single article that you have a problem with,. I sincerely hope that one day when you need something from the PD or the mayor, they dont shut you out for the way you speak about them.
Natalie Davis
10:48 pm on Friday, November 30, 2012
Interesting comment, Ange. I am curious: Do you really think public servants should serve only those who claim to support them or keep their complaints to themselves? Do you want to live in the kind of town where people are afraid to speak out or say what they really believe or hold accountable town officials (who are citizens' employees, after all) for fear of reprisal?
Scott Dean
9:51 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
"Fear of Reprisal" I think that can fit on the towns billboard at the corner of
Vail and 46
gina s.
10:18 pm on Saturday, December 1, 2012
I think ange is just giving her opinion too just like Robyn always does. The problem is that way too many people give others a hard time for doing just that....expressing their opinion. There are certain people on patch that are simply bullies. They constantly give people a hard time for saying what they feel.
Robyn M.
11:36 pm on Saturday, December 1, 2012
People should feel they can speak their mind, without being insulted. Comments like "you have nothing good to say..." have nothing to do with the article above them. They are about other posters. I was commenting on the article and agreeing with the essence of it - the Mayor often changes his tune, when confronted with facts/reality. And, as to what Natalie says - I immediately thought that, too. You do not pay your taxes to assist in running the town and expect the town to only assist those who compliment them.