New Details Surface in Clerk's Office Dispute

Legal fights pit the clerk's employees against the former clerk and both against town leaders

More information is surfacing in the mysterious . Four employees in the clerk's office—including one who retired over the matter—say Johnson created a hostile workplace for them. In response, they are taking legal action against town leadership and the former clerk.

Attorney Gina Mendola Longarzo said she has filed a tort claim, in essence a motion of intent to sue for $4 million, in the names of former employee Tonae Bettelli and current staffers Cara Fox, Leslie Miller and Janet Zorsky.

Among those named as defendants in the action are Mayor James Barberio, Personnel Director Hank Sunyak, Business Administrator Jasmine Lim, the five Town Council members and Johnson.

Longarzo told Patch that trouble started shortly after Johnson took over for her veteran predecessor, Judith Silver, last Aug. 1.

Almost immediately, said Longarzo, clerk employees reported that Johnson made racial, sexual and religious comments that made them feel uncomfortable in the office.

Johnson "made some inappropriate comments about whether she had feelings for... Ms. Betelli," the attorney said, recounting her clients' accusations. "She made comments that [Parsippany] was a lily-white town and that people didn't know why she was working there and that she would say, 'Back in my other job, I didn't have these issues and the people understood me.'"

Longarzo said Betelli and her colleagues also accuse Johnson of threatening violence.

"[According to the clients], she told one client that in the old days, she would take her out into the parking lot and put her fists up, saying that she would get into a fight with her," the lawyer alleged. "She mentioned that she had guns and was not afraid to use them.

"These four ladies, who had worked with the town for a long time, were very uncomfortable," Longarzo said, adding that the women did not know where to turn.

According to the attorney, Betelli filed a complaint with the administration 10 days after Johnson started the job.

"No corrective action was taken. The administration sided with Mrs. Johnson and basically told my client to just deal with it," said Longarzo. "It got so bad that Ms. Betelli was forced to retire because she couldn't take it anymore. Her doctor said she couldn't go back to work under those conditions."

The attorney said her clients allege that town officials were not supportive and even retaliatory.

In the tort claim documents published by Parsippany Life, the clerk's employees allege that Mayor Barberio swore at Leslie Miller after she filed another complaint in October.

Johnson also retained an attorney to file a complaint over a hostile work environment  and, after four months on the job, took a work-related medical leave that lasted until her employment ended.

Confirmation of the break between Johnson and the township came at the end of March.

Longarzo said she was aware of similar legal actions filed by Johnson.

"We find that amusing," she said.

Neither Johnson nor her attorney, Stephan Mashel, have returned requests for comment.

Town employees named in the tort claim have been advised by their attorney not to comment on the matter. Those who work within town hall are unavailable as the building is closed for Good Friday.

Screech Owl April 08, 2012 at 02:28 PM
Parsippany Life has a very interesting, expanded story on As The Townhall Turns. I have visited this film set often for many years. The administration may not want to admit that they made a mistake with their choice of hire but the girls who filed the suit are in no way qualified even or "reportedly" qualified for the position of a township clerk. They range from less then one to less then three years experience in the office and the inexperience shows right along with their work ethic. It would seem the marriage between Ms. Johnson and the girls was a perfect match.
VietNam Vet April 09, 2012 at 04:33 AM
Sounds to me like Tonae Betteli was close to retiring and wanted a nice little payout to retire on. Something just doesn't smell right here. There goes a our taxes again!
Lee Mo April 09, 2012 at 11:23 AM
Biddies on autpilot? 1 woman was there for 19 years. She is the only one who filed a suit after 10 days. The other 3 were not there for all those years and did not file suit initially. How can you make a judgement that 4 women would all of a sudden risk their jobs and file a lawsuit? How can you assume that Ms. Johnson within 10 days was "making them accountable" and it drove them to be upset about that? In those 10 days she created a hostile environment - and when the current office members went to complain - and nothing was done - they had no other choice. "Johnson made racial, sexual and religious comments that made them feel uncomfortable in the office" - THAT is what is the claim. They did not sue because they had to work. I am sure that is documented along with the times they escalated their complaints that went unaddressed.
Lee Mo April 09, 2012 at 11:27 AM
Really? Then how do you explain the other 3 joining the suit - who were NOT there nearly as long? Remember the town has great benefits. In this environment who would risk a job that has decent hours and benefits - on a lawsuit that may or may not be won? You don't know the age or time in of these employees.
VietNam Vet April 10, 2012 at 04:08 AM
They would risk the job because of this towns luck, this town has had to pay out on every claim that was put to them. Parsippany has the reputation for losing any lawsuits. Can you tell me one that they didn't have to payout on?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »