Mayor Helps Couple Threatened with Eviction

Barberio said law designed to prevent apartment overcrowding wasn't intended to hurt small families.

A distraught married couple with a disabled child, facing threatened eviction from their apartment, turned to the Township Council and the mayor for help--and got it.

Ranya Tawfik, a tenant of on Baldwin Road,  stood before the council and pleaded their case

"I'm currently in the process of being evicted from the apartment I've resided in for 12 years," she said.

The story involves an ordinance in existence that limits the number of people who can live in a one-bedroom apartment based on the square footage of the dwelling.

Tawfik said that when their daughter, who is disabled, was born four years ago, she and her husband suddenly were in violation of the law.

Their living situation was not a secret.

"Two years ago... an inspector came in and noticed that there wasn't any overcrowding," she told the council.

It became a problem last Friday morning, Tawfik said.

Despite the fact that they created a separate sleeping space for the child in the apartment's dining room, Tawfik said Housing Coordinator Rena Plaxe informed the couple that, under the ordinance, their bedroom was approximately 25 square feet too small to permit a third resident in the space. 

"She gave us 30 days to move," she told Patch. "We pleaded for more time and she gave us 60 days to leave the premises or we would be out on the street."

Tawfik said she went to the mayor's office and was turned away, so she instead went to the governor, who said that Mayor James Barberio had to handle the situation.

"It was a misunderstanding, you weren't turned away," the mayor said.

She added that while at Town Hall she was given a recommendation to move to another apartment in Mill Gardens.  That dwelling, Tawfik said was a one-bedroom domicile that met the ordinance requirements, however the apartment as a whole was more expensive and its total area was 55 square feet less than the Dartmouth Village flat.

"I don't understand where the logic comes in with overcrowding when I'm asked to move into a smaller apartment," Tawfik said.

The mayor said he would be happy to discuss the issue with Tawfik and her husband after the meeting.

"Don't worry, you will not be out in the streets," he said.

Immediately after the meeting's end, Barberio met with the couple and told them that given the 12 years Tawfik has been in the apartment, a grandfather clause should allow them to stay in their home.

The couple were elated and relieved.

"I have not been able to sleep or eat over this," Tawfik said. "We are so grateful to the mayor, who was never the problem. He is a great mayor and did the right thing."

"The problem is the ordinance," the mayor told Patch. "We are going to have to change it. It was supposed to address overcrowding. It was not intended to go after young families like this."

Barberio said he couldn't speak for the landlord "who was upholding the ordinance and has certain rights as well."

Dartmouth Village is managed by Landmark Companies in Keasbey.

The mayor would not comment in regard to Plaxe's performance.

Ted Nugent May 17, 2012 at 08:22 PM
I'll comment regarding Plaxe's performance! I too was unjustly put through hardship due to Plaxe's incompetence, arrogance and a complete lack of integrity. Only after several appearances in court and of course retaining a lawyer was Plaxe forced to drop all charges. And get this... the charges were that I basically wasn't allowed to have 16" long logs which I was splitting for fire wood in my yard!
paul May 18, 2012 at 03:17 AM
this is just one of many complaints of plaxe's bad jobs with the town.she must be one of the good old boys
rug May 18, 2012 at 10:36 AM
I would seem this administration itself is afraid of her. I read and hear so many outrageous things the woman has done yet she remains. Her strongest asset is picking on the weak, down, elderly and cash strapped residents which reflects on the current Mayor. Maybe he told her it is O.K. to do so.
Bob Crawford May 18, 2012 at 10:39 AM
When questioned as to who was in charge at the White House, former President Harry S. Truman was famous for saying that "The buck stops here" Wonder where the buck stops in Parsippany's Town Hall these days
Carol M. May 18, 2012 at 11:52 AM
I am in complete agreement with you here Mr. Crawford. I have found this department to be inefficient and problematic on so many levels and no doubt, the ultimate responsibility must lie with the top.
enabler May 19, 2012 at 01:02 AM
With such rampant stacking violations going on in this town, exceptions should under now circumstances be made. I for one am sick and tired of paying someone elses taxes. A one bedroom apt. allows for two inhabitants, end of story. It's time for these folks to move into a two bedroom apts.
Frank Drebin May 19, 2012 at 01:48 AM
Great publicity stunt Mr Mayor. If you are so concerned in public why did you walk out the backdoor when the Patel family waited hours to see you? Who made up the grandfather clause?
Shutterclick May 19, 2012 at 02:16 AM
Plaxe was a nightmare when she was at Troy Hills Village! Nasty, rude, incompetant and the apartments were a disaster. She treated people poorly. And to think she's after someone NOW for overcrowding? When she ran Troy Hills Village, there were TONS of apartments with 4,5 and even 6 people living in them. Parsippany's housing doesn't care about its renters at all!
parhome May 19, 2012 at 02:24 AM
Had dealings with Ms Plaxe. She was insensitive, rude and unprofessional. Not a nice person.
VietNam Vet May 19, 2012 at 05:45 AM
It sound like this Plaxe has something on someone thats why she hasn't been FIRED yet. I was told by the town one time, " We are the local Government, we can do what we want". It looks like they sure as heck try too, and they get away with it. The mayor stepped inhere to right something so now he comes off looking like the Hero here. Yeah right!!!!!!!!!!
charleschap May 19, 2012 at 12:03 PM
Who is the older gentleman in the permits department I see sleeping in a chair out in full view? I want his job. I checked last Sunday's paper but I didn't see any openings for sleeping on the job. Wonder what that pays?
Scott Dean May 19, 2012 at 12:51 PM
Permits and ordinances are in the category of lets see who notices, How bout building structures that our kids play in on town property with no drawings or permits,I was hoping for the thank you for saving town being saved from a possible lawsuit..Maybe they will repay the favor for me down the road. Scott


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something